How An Agency Decides Not To Pitch
Every agency has a story about the pitch it won and should not have. Fewer talk about the harder call, which is deciding not to pitch at all, before a single deck exists.
A pitch is not free. It is four to six weeks of the strongest people in the building, working nights on work nobody has commissioned. The question is never whether the brief is interesting. It is whether the agency can afford to find out.
The signals that say not to pitch
Most of them arrive in the first meeting. A brief with no decision maker in the room. A timeline that assumes the agency has nothing else running. Six agencies on the list and no chemistry stage. A scope that keeps growing in the conversation while the fee stays where it started.
None of these is fatal on its own. Three together usually mean the brand has not finished deciding what it wants, and the pitch is the process it is using to decide.
The cost nobody puts in the deck
The real price of a speculative pitch is paid by existing clients, because the people pulled onto it are the people already running live work. The Advertising Agencies Association of India has argued for years that pitch conduct and remuneration deserve their own standards for exactly this reason.
Who actually makes the call
Rarely the creative department. It is usually the business lead and the head of the agency, with the creative director asked one question: can we win this with the people who are free? If the honest answer needs a person who is on air next month, the answer is no.
How to decline without closing the door
The agencies that do this well decline in person, early, and give a reason that is about capacity rather than the brand. They often offer a smaller piece of work instead, a strategy sprint or a single film, which costs the client less and proves the same thing.
A brief declined cleanly in September is frequently the same brief, uncontested, in March.
More from Creative Room.