Your Daily Dose of Ad World Buzz
Latest
✦How To Ask For A Promotion In An Agency✦UltraTech Cement Names Hrishikesh Warekar Lead, Marketing And Growth✦A Voice Is Wildly Yours, But Never Yours✦Hungama Appoints Vishnu Kanth Gokul B As Chief Revenue Officer✦WPP Media Appoints Jobin Jose As Vice President, Client Service✦T-Series And Hungama Launch Micro-Drama Platform FastTV With Rs 300 Crore✦Daawat Delight's New Film With Ranveer Brar Pitches Flavour Absorption✦JioStar Appoints Vineet Sharma As Business Head, MTV And Youth Entertainment✦IndiaFirst Life's 'Azadi Agents' Campaign By The Womb Celebrates Insurance Agents✦Comviva Partners Grameenphone To Upgrade SMS, USSD And Messaging Security✦IndiGo Appoints Vijay Nair As Head Of Brand Marketing✦Publicis Media Appoints Rohin Desai As Senior Vice President✦How To Ask For A Promotion In An Agency✦UltraTech Cement Names Hrishikesh Warekar Lead, Marketing And Growth✦A Voice Is Wildly Yours, But Never Yours✦Hungama Appoints Vishnu Kanth Gokul B As Chief Revenue Officer✦WPP Media Appoints Jobin Jose As Vice President, Client Service✦T-Series And Hungama Launch Micro-Drama Platform FastTV With Rs 300 Crore✦Daawat Delight's New Film With Ranveer Brar Pitches Flavour Absorption✦JioStar Appoints Vineet Sharma As Business Head, MTV And Youth Entertainment✦IndiaFirst Life's 'Azadi Agents' Campaign By The Womb Celebrates Insurance Agents✦Comviva Partners Grameenphone To Upgrade SMS, USSD And Messaging Security✦IndiGo Appoints Vijay Nair As Head Of Brand Marketing✦Publicis Media Appoints Rohin Desai As Senior Vice President
The Ai Shift

Generated Images And The Stereotype Problem

Ad Tribe Editorial2 min read
A flat vector character painting over a row of identical figures to make each one different

Ask a generator for an Indian family, a farmer, a wedding or an office, and what comes back is recognisable, competent and narrow. Generated images of Indian life tend to arrive pre-averaged.

The result is rarely crude enough to be called offensive. It is something duller and more commercially damaging: a version of the country assembled from the pictures that were already online in the largest numbers, which is not the same as the country.

What Generated Images Get Wrong About India

Class, mostly. Interiors come back tidier and wealthier than the brief suggested, or, if poverty is requested, exaggerated into a picture of scarcity that no brand would run.

Region comes second. The default wedding, the default kitchen and the default street tend towards a small set of visual conventions that flatten a lot of differences an Indian audience reads instantly.

And period. A surprising amount of generated Indian imagery looks like 2012, because that is when a great deal of the available reference material was made.

The tool is not describing India. It is describing the photographs of India that happened to be indexed.

Why This Is A Commercial Problem

Because specificity is what makes advertising work. A room that looks like a real family's room earns attention that a generically pleasant room does not, and the whole craft of casting and art direction in Indian advertising has been built on getting that right.

A team that accepts the first plausible output is not being unethical. It is being less interesting than the brief needed, which is a failure the client will feel without being able to name.

The Working Practice

Brief like a photographer: name the city, the income, the year, the material of the floor. Reject the first plausible image as a matter of routine. And keep a real reference set, shot or sourced, that shows the tool what this brand's version of the country looks like.

Related: what affordable regional advertising changes.

More in The AI Shift.

Follow Ad Tribe