Can Talent From Tier 2 And Tier 3 India Change Agency Creativity
An industry that sells to a billion people hires from about four cities, and then spends a fortune on research to understand everyone in tier 2 and tier 3 India it did not hire.
The concentration made sense when the work had to be made where the clients and the production were. It made less sense the moment briefings, edits and reviews moved onto a screen, and it makes least sense now, when a growing share of the audience being targeted lives in the places nobody is hired from.
What tier 2 and tier 3 hiring would actually change
Not tone. The idea that a creative from a smaller city writes warmer or more rooted copy is a stereotype, and it is usually deployed to keep those hires in the regional-language corner of the department.
What changes is the reference set. Every creative department has shared assumptions about what is aspirational, what is funny and what is embarrassing, and those assumptions are local to the few neighbourhoods everybody in the room grew up in. Widening the roster widens the set of things somebody in the room can recognise as wrong.
The hardest thing to hire for is somebody who can tell you the work is not landing, and mean it about a place you have never lived.
Why it has not happened yet
Three reasons, none of them about talent. Portfolios are read against a template that portfolio schools in the metros teach. Interviews reward fluency in English and in agency jargon, which is a proxy for exposure rather than ability. And hybrid work quietly re-centred the office, so the person who cannot drop into the Friday review is not in the running for the interesting brief.
What would make it real
Judging portfolios on thinking rather than finish, since polish is a function of the equipment somebody had access to. Running at least one brief a quarter with a fully distributed team, so remote is a normal way to work rather than an accommodation. And paying the same rate for the same role regardless of where the person sits, which is where most good intentions quietly collapse.
The prize is not virtue. It is an agency that can tell, before the campaign runs, that a line which plays beautifully in one city means nothing three hours away.
More on Ad Tribe Work Life.