Your Daily Dose of Ad World Buzz
Latest
✦How To Ask For A Promotion In An Agency✦UltraTech Cement Names Hrishikesh Warekar Lead, Marketing And Growth✦A Voice Is Wildly Yours, But Never Yours✦Hungama Appoints Vishnu Kanth Gokul B As Chief Revenue Officer✦WPP Media Appoints Jobin Jose As Vice President, Client Service✦T-Series And Hungama Launch Micro-Drama Platform FastTV With Rs 300 Crore✦Daawat Delight's New Film With Ranveer Brar Pitches Flavour Absorption✦JioStar Appoints Vineet Sharma As Business Head, MTV And Youth Entertainment✦IndiaFirst Life's 'Azadi Agents' Campaign By The Womb Celebrates Insurance Agents✦Comviva Partners Grameenphone To Upgrade SMS, USSD And Messaging Security✦IndiGo Appoints Vijay Nair As Head Of Brand Marketing✦Publicis Media Appoints Rohin Desai As Senior Vice President✦How To Ask For A Promotion In An Agency✦UltraTech Cement Names Hrishikesh Warekar Lead, Marketing And Growth✦A Voice Is Wildly Yours, But Never Yours✦Hungama Appoints Vishnu Kanth Gokul B As Chief Revenue Officer✦WPP Media Appoints Jobin Jose As Vice President, Client Service✦T-Series And Hungama Launch Micro-Drama Platform FastTV With Rs 300 Crore✦Daawat Delight's New Film With Ranveer Brar Pitches Flavour Absorption✦JioStar Appoints Vineet Sharma As Business Head, MTV And Youth Entertainment✦IndiaFirst Life's 'Azadi Agents' Campaign By The Womb Celebrates Insurance Agents✦Comviva Partners Grameenphone To Upgrade SMS, USSD And Messaging Security✦IndiGo Appoints Vijay Nair As Head Of Brand Marketing✦Publicis Media Appoints Rohin Desai As Senior Vice President
Social First

Why Brands Banter With Other Brands In The Comments

Ad Tribe! Bureau3 min read
Two cut faces resting on a torn band and eyeing each other over a floating table tennis ball, the back-and-forth of brand banter

When brands banter with other brands in the comments, it can look like an accident: a social media manager at one company spots a post from another and cannot resist a reply. Sometimes it is exactly that. More often it is a habit Indian social teams have learned on purpose, because a good line under someone else's post can travel further than anything on the brand's own feed.

It is the cheapest media buy on the internet. It is also one of the easiest to get wrong.

Why brands banter in other brands' comments

Because the audience is already there. A reply under a popular post from a food app, a telecom operator or a streaming service is seen by that account's followers, many of whom have never visited the replying brand's page. A sharp comment earns likes, gets pinned or screenshotted, and is shared as a moment rather than as an advert.

It also shows character in a way a planned post cannot. A brand that can take a joke and return one reads as relaxed and human. That is valuable for categories where the product is ordinary and the personality has to do the selling.

A reply under someone else's post is a guest appearance. The best guests make the host look good too.

What makes the exchange work

Both sides being in on it. The banter that people enjoy is between brands with a friendly rivalry or no rivalry at all, where the tease is affectionate and the other brand is happy to answer. It feels like two colleagues joking across a desk.

Speed matters, which means the team needs room to act. A reply that waits two days for approval is no longer a reply. The brands that do this well agree in advance what their social team may say without sign-off, and what always goes to a senior person. We looked at what a single strong reply needs in the anatomy of a great brand reply.

And it has to include the audience. The exchanges that last are the ones ordinary users join, adding their own jokes underneath. If only brands are laughing, nobody else is.

Where brand banter goes wrong

When the joke becomes a claim. A comment saying a rival's product is worse is still a comparison, and the ASCI code expects comparisons to be factual and not misleading, and advertisers not to unfairly denigrate other products. A brand's own comment is part of its communication, however casual it looks.

When it punches down. Mocking a small business, a regional brand or a customer who complained may get a laugh from some, but it reads as a large company bullying a smaller one, and screenshots outlive the thread.

And when everyone joins. A thread where a dozen brands queue up with variations of the same pun stops being funny around the fourth reply. Audiences have learned to spot the pile-on, and many now find it tiresome rather than charming.

How to decide whether to reply

Ask three questions. Would the other brand enjoy this? Would a customer reading it smile, or wince? And does the line sound like the brand, or like every other brand that day?

If any answer is unclear, the safer move is to stay quiet. Silence costs nothing. A bad reply under someone else's post can follow a brand for years.

More from Social-First.

Follow Ad Tribe